An unsuitable investment is one that does not fit the person it was recommended to, judged by facts such as age, income needs, time horizon, and tolerance for risk. The product itself may be legitimate; the problem is the mismatch. For a retiree living on savings, a recommendation that adds risk, ties up money, or generates heavy fees can be hard to recover from.
What Makes an Investment Unsuitable for a Retiree?
Under Regulation Best Interest, a federal rule for brokers, a broker must have a reasonable basis to believe a recommendation is in the best interest of the particular customer, based on that customer’s investment profile. A suitable investment can still lose money, so a loss alone does not prove misconduct. The question is whether the recommendation fit the retiree when it was made.
How Do Brokers Take Advantage of Retirees?
Brokers can take advantage of older investors in several ways:
- Annuities that do not fit: The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), which oversees brokerage firms, requires under FINRA Rule 2330 that a broker recommending a deferred variable annuity ask about the customer’s age and liquidity needs (how soon cash may be needed) and explain surrender charges, the fees for cashing out early.
- Concentration: Placing most of a retirement portfolio in one risky sector or product.
- Unauthorized trades: Buying or selling without the retiree’s approval.
- Churning: Trading an account excessively to generate commissions.
What Are the Warning Signs?
Signs worth a closer look in an account statement include:
- Products that appear without a clear conversation, such as annuities, alternative investments, or a margin account
- A jump in trading activity compared with past years
- Statements that no longer match what the broker described
- A broker who avoids questions or discourages a second opinion
One sign alone may have an innocent explanation; several together are a stronger signal. FINRA also runs a Securities Helpline for Seniors where older investors can raise concerns about how an account was handled.
How Long Do Retirees Have to File a Claim in Florida?
Under section 95.11 of the Florida Statutes, a claim under Florida’s securities law generally must be filed within two years after the retiree discovered, or should have discovered, the facts behind it, and no more than five years after the violation. A fraud claim generally has four years from discovery. Many disputes go to FINRA arbitration, a private process that takes the place of a lawsuit, where FINRA Rule 12206 bars claims filed more than six years after the event behind them.
Concerned About an Unsuitable Investment?
Finding out that retirement savings were steered into investments that never fit is painful, for retirees and for the family members helping them. Our team at Savage Villoch Law, PLLC secured a victory of over $15.4 million that recovered the life savings of a retired couple. If an unsuitable investment has eaten into a nest egg, contact us or call 813-251-4890 to request a free case study.
Posted In: Securities Fraud